# Forum: Analog Circuits LED to LED receiver

Rate this post
 • ▲ useful ▼ not useful
Hello,
I have been trying to make a LED to LED transmission work with 2 LED's.
Now I do receive some signal but the problem is that the receiver
diode's capacitance is apparently pretty high so it takes a pretty long
time to discharge it, which makes it that the signal builds up and down
over time.

The receiver is just built from a voltage follower with an opamp that
has very high input impedance, a high pass to filter out the DC part of
the ambient light and a non inverting amplifier.
Also I can use only positive supply voltage.
Now one of the reasons the signal even gets worse is that after the high
pass the signal is partly negative which can make some of the 1's very
hard to notice even after amplification.
Now I think I would be able to recover the signal if it strong enough
but maybe some of you guys have an idea how to improve the signal.

I have attached a picture of the signal before(orange) and after(green)
filtering.
Also I have a picture of the amplified signal.

Rate this post
 • ▲ useful ▼ not useful
Jocculator wrote:
> The receiver is just built from a voltage follower
Any kind of schematics available?

> is that after the high pass the signal is partly negative
How can this be?

: Edited by Moderator

Rate this post
 • ▲ useful ▼ not useful
Without a circuit diagram there's no way we can help improve your
project. What frequency ranges do you try to amplify?

Rate this post
 • ▲ useful ▼ not useful
I am not trying to amplify a very high frequency signal.
Maybe I can get it up to 1kHz that would be great and sufficient
already.
I have put a picture of the schematic.
The Voltage over a Capacitance is proportional to the integral of the
current over time. Since the current sometimes is negative since the
capacitance charges and discharges the voltage will also be sometimes
negative.

Rate this post
 • ▲ useful ▼ not useful
It would be helpful sense to provide the values of the resistores.

Without having tried it by myself: I would suggest to use a trans
impedance Amplifier instead of a voltage follower for the left part of
the circuit.

Rate this post
 • ▲ useful ▼ not useful
R2 220k, R3 100k, R4 1k
Transimpedance converter doesn't work in this case since the current is
way too low. I tried it and I just cannot get a voltage at the output.
I also tried transimpedance with a reverse bias voltage to increase
photocurrent and it didn't work.

Rate this post
 • ▲ useful ▼ not useful
Jocculator wrote:
> since the current is way too low.
No way to increase it?
Because when your signal is kind of pure noise(**) it looks like in
"Signal_before_and_after_filter.png", then you will not find any kind of
circuit to "descramble" that.

(**) at least I don't recognize anything akin a binary signal therein.

Rate this post
 • ▲ useful ▼ not useful
No I don't think I have an easy way to increase it. Since I have only a
positive supply voltage I can't really bias the diode very easily.
I did try to bias it via a virtual ground but that didn't really improve
the signal.
The Signal looks like that because the LED has a capacitive effect and I
can't really change that.

Rate this post
 • ▲ useful ▼ not useful
Jocculator wrote:
> The Signal looks like
Whats the payload in it? What do you want to get out of it?

Rate this post
 • ▲ useful ▼ not useful
What I want to get out of it? It's not really clear but most likely some
error codes so not really much information at all. That's why I'm
contempt with the low bit rates.

Rate this post
 • ▲ useful ▼ not useful
Jocculator wrote:
> What I want to get out of it?
What information (aka 0 and 1 bits) is hidden in the noise of your
screenshots?

Rate this post
 • ▲ useful ▼ not useful
Hi.
You use a LED as receiver ? Please specify the partnumbers of both LEDs.
Best regards

Rate this post
 • ▲ useful ▼ not useful
You must the Fotodiode umdrehen and the Verstärkung from the Amplifier
must be higher. Put a 1M Resistor in the Leitung from PIN 7 to 6 and
überbrücke ihn for example with 10pF.

Ich weiß, mein Englisch ist nicht so gut, aber ich habe keine Lust, in
meinem Alter nochmal zum Englischkurs zu gehen.

Rate this post
 • ▲ useful ▼ not useful
I use OSRAM 6-lead in-line MULTILED LRTB GFTG. for both transmission and
receiver I use the blue LED.
But I probably will from now on try out other LED's.
As far as I could see there is no built in extra capacitance.
So it must be the inherent capacitance of the LED itself.

Rate this post
 • ▲ useful ▼ not useful
A LED as a receiver can work. But it depends on the type of LED.
Better use a dedicated photodiode or photoresistor instead.

Rate this post
 • ▲ useful ▼ not useful
Hier in deutsch für dich :)
Als ich ausgetestet habe wo ich ein Signal mit der LED empfangen kann
habe ich festgestellt, dass es bei einem Spannungsfolger keinen
Unterschied macht, wie rum ich die LED schalte außer, dass sich das
Vorzeichen der Spannung ändert. Da ich aber nur positive
Versorgungsspannung benutzen kann muss ich die LED in Durchlassrichtung
schalten sonst funktioniert der OPamp leider nicht.
Ok du willst quasi, dass ich nicht einfach so rückkoppele sondern mit
einem 1M und 10pf parallel. Was für eine Schaltung wäre das dann und was
würde es bewirken?

Rate this post
 • ▲ useful ▼ not useful
Have a look on this project. It could help you a lot:
https://hackaday.com/2019/12/22/optical-communication-using-leds-alone/

Rate this post
 • ▲ useful ▼ not useful
Wow I just used other LED's and it worked perfectly without any
filtering.
I am honestly so confused. Anybody know why those particular LED's have
that capacitive behaviour? I have tried 2 different RGB LED's from OSRAM
and they both behaved the same so its probably just how they work
because I didn't see any capacitors in the datasheets.

Please log in before posting. Registration is free and takes only a minute.
Existing account
 User name or e-mail address Password
Do you have a Google/GoogleMail account? No registration required!
Log in with Google account
No account? Register here.